The PCNA Protein and Mismatch Repair

Italicized portions of this news release from Duke University Medical Center- How DNA Repair Machinery is a 'Two-Way Street'- are posted below with my comments.

DURHAM, N.C. -- Biochemists at Duke University Medical Center have discovered key components that enable the cell's DNA repair machinery to adeptly launch its action in either direction along a DNA strand to strip out faulty DNA. Such flexibility exemplifies the power of the repair machinery, which guards cells against mutations by editing out errors that occur during the process of chromosome replication. Malfunction of the "mismatch repair" machinery is the cause of several types of cancer, including relatively common forms of colon cancer.

DNA repair functions are essential to the survival of living organisms. When they malfunction consequences are generally disastrous for the affected organism. Cancer is a mentioned effect.

Modrich and his colleagues have long studied the mismatch repair machinery of the cell. This machinery detects and corrects errors in DNA replication in which the wrong DNA unit is stitched into place in a newly forming DNA strand. Normally such units -- called nucleotides -- on one strand of the double-stranded DNA molecule bond with complementary nucleotides on the other strand, like complementary pieces of a puzzle. Thus, an adenine on one strand is normally paired with a thymine on the other, and a guanine on one strand with a cytosine on another.

The process of mismatch repair involves first recognizing the mismatch -- for example of an adenine with a cytosine. The machinery then recognizes a break in the newly synthesized DNA strand, which triggers the machinery to excise the section including the mismatch, starting at the strand break and working toward the mismatch and slightly beyond. The system then replaces the mismatched strand with one containing the correct complementary nucleotide.

A central mystery is how the mismatch repair system is flexible enough to recognize such a triggering strand break on either side of the mismatch along the DNA strand, said Modrich. In the Molecular Cell paper, he and his colleagues have defined the protein components of the machinery that allows such bidirectionality and figured out how those components assemble at the strand break to direct the excision.

Importantly, the researchers' biochemical experiments and analyses of mutations in the repair proteins revealed how the machinery for excising the faulty DNA strand "knows" which way to go from the strand break to the mismatch.

Basically, they found that a protein called PCNA is clamped onto the DNA at the strand break. PCNA, together with the protein that clamps PCNA onto the DNA double helix, regulate the enzyme whose job it is to snip out the segment containing the mismatch, by "aiming" the enzyme -- called exonuclease I -- in the right direction to work itself along the strand, stripping out the segment containing the mismatch.

Exonuclease I, while essential, is insufficient to accomplish the function at hand without assistence. The assistence comes from two clamping proteins one of which is identified as PCNA. Skeptics of mainstream evolutionary theory point to mechanisms like this as inadaquately explained by gene duplication and protein homology.

"A surprising feature of the repair system that it can evaluate the placement of the strand signal to one side or the other of the mismatch and work from there," said Modrich. According to Modrich placement of the strand break that directs repair to one side or the other of the mismatch is likely a consequence of the mechanism by which DNA is copied by the replication machinery.

"This system does more than just repair DNA biosynthetic errors," he said. "Many cancer chemotherapeutic drugs work by damaging DNA, which selectively kills cancer cells because they are proliferating more than resting cells. The mismatch repair machinery senses certain types of DNA damage, which leads to activation of the cell's suicide machinery, called apoptosis, resulting in cell death. Inactivation of the mismatch repair system not only predisposes cells to tumor development, but also renders them resistant to certain anti-tumor drugs.

The study of DNA repair mechanisms is interesting from an intelligent design perspective. However it also yields many practical medical benefits.